Left

CivilFEM Online Help

Official Websites: CivilFEM | CivilFEM Licenses | Ingeciber
CivilFEM powered by Marc: Installation | Documentation | Python Guide | Theory Manual | Verification Manual | PDF | Class 3
CivilFEM for Ansys: Installation | Documentation | Verification Manual | Instalación | Documentación | PDF | PDF (ES) | Class 3
CivilFEM Apps for Ansys Workbench: Installation | Licensing | FAQ | Reinforced Concrete | Structural Steel | Theory Manual | PDF | Class 3
Right

CFVR3215 - Slope stability with water pressure, seism and forces (PLANE2)

Slope stability analysis, with water pressure, an impermeable layer, seismic acceleration and punctual forces.

A plane model as shown in the figure is used to check the slope stability analysis. Fellenius, Bishop, Janbu and Modified Janbu methods are used.
The model is made off four layers of materials with the following properties (from top to bottom):

  • Specific weight 1 = 12600 N/m2; Porosity 1 = 0.10
  • Specific weight 2 = 14400 N/m2
  • Specific weight 3 = 11200 N/m2; Porosity 3 = 0.40
  • Specific weight 4 = 9000 N/m2; Porosity 4 = 0.10
The terrain has a water table defined as a polygonal line. The second layer is considered impermeable, no water pore pressure will act on it (RUSI=0).
The actions on the structure are self weight, a horizontal acceleration due to seismic actions of 0.30g and a puntual force on the slope with the following components:
  • FX = -948600 N
  • FY = -316220 N
This example is the same as CFVR3205 using PLANE42 elements instead of PLANE82 elements.

Element types used in the model: PLANE42

Needed CivilFEM Modules:
Geotechnical Module
Bridges and Civil Non Linearities Module
Advanced Prestressed Concrete Module

The example can be launched on an educational license.
KEYWORDS
Geotechnics
Slope Stability


Model Statistics
Number of elements 198
Number of nodes 228
Number of civil materials 4
Number of cross sections 0
Number of shell vertices 0

Log file: CFVR3215.DAT


  FINISH
  ~CFCLEAR,,1
  ~CFACTIV,GETC,Y
  NomFile='CFVR3215'
  /TITLE, %NomFile%, Slope stability with water pressure, seism and forces (PLANE2)

! -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
! 1. Initial data
! -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
! CivilFEM SETUP
  ~UNITS,SI

/PREP7
! 2. Materials
! --------------------------------------------------
~CFMP,1,LIB,SOIL,,OH
~CFMP,2,LIB,SOIL,,CH
~CFMP,3,LIB,SOIL,,SC
~CFMP,4,LIB,SOIL,,PH
~CFMP,1,Soil,GAMD,,12600 ! OH
~CFMP,2,Soil,GAMD,,14400 ! CH
~CFMP,3,Soil,GAMD,,11200 ! SC
~CFMP,4,Soil,GAMD,,9000  ! PH
*DO,II,1,4
  ~CFMP,II,SOIL,RUSI,,1
*ENDDO
~CFMP,2,SOIL,RUSI,,0

! 3. Elements
! --------------------------------------------------
ET,1,PLANE42

! 4. MODEL
! --------------------------------------------------
K, 1,-12,28
K, 2,  1,29
K, 3, 10,37
K, 4, 19,38
K, 5, 35,28
K, 6, 50,27
K, 7,  6,33
K, 8, 20,29
K, 9, 26,34
K,10, 18,24
K,11, 50,21
K,12,-12,19
K,13, 50,16
K,14,-12, 6
K,15, 50,10
A,7,8,9,4,3
A,2,7,8,9,5,6,11,10
A,1,2,10,11,13,12
A,15,13,12,14

AESIZE,ALL,3

*DO,I,1,4
  MAT,I
  AMESH,I
*ENDDO

! 5. Capturing Model
! --------------------------------------------------
pp1=node(kx(1),ky(1),kz(1))
pp2=node(kx(6),ky(6),kz(6))
pp3=node(kx(5),ky(5),kz(5))
pp9=node(kx(9),ky(9),kz(9))
F,pp9,FX,-948600
F,pp9,FY,-316220
~SLPIN,PP1,PP2,PP3

/PBC,ALL,,1
/NUMBER,1
/PNUM,MAT,1
EPLOT
/IMAGE, SAVE, %NomFile%,BMP

! 6. Circles Centres Grid Input
! --------------------------------------------------
K,16,21,41
K,17,35,32
K,18,42,43
k,19,28,52
~SLPCIRK,16,19,17,5,6

! 7. Tangents Input
! --------------------------------------------------
K,20,34,27
K,21,34,11
K,22, 0,11
K,23,18,37
~SLPTANK,20,23,22,21,10

! 8. Hydrostatic Pressure
! --------------------------------------------------
~SLPPWP,5,0,-12,27, 01,27, 16,35, 41,25, 50,25

! 9. Data Check
! --------------------------------------------------
! Data comparison number
  NComp    = 30*4
  NComp_ch = 0

! Marix dim.
  *DIM,LABEL,CHAR,Ncomp,1
  *DIM,LABEL_CH,CHAR,Ncomp_ch,1
  *DIM,VALUE,,Ncomp,3
  *DIM,VALUE_CH,CHAR,Ncomp_ch,3
  *DIM,TOLER,,Ncomp,2

! 10. Labels, Correct data, obtained data
! --------------------------------------------------
*DIM,AUXVECT,ARRAY,10
*DIM,AUXVEC2,ARRAY,10
/POST1
~SLPSOL,0,,0.3 ! Fellenius
*DO,JJ,1,30
  LABEL(JJ) = 'FEL' %JJ%
  *DO,II,1,10
    ~CFGET,AUXVECT(II),SLOPE,,RES,F,,2,(JJ-1)*10 + II
  *ENDDO
  *VOPER,AUXVEC2,AUXVECT,MULT,AUXVECT
  *VFUN,AUXVEC2,SQRT,AUXVEC2
  *VFUN,AUXVEC2,ASORT,AUXVEC2
  VALUE(JJ,2) = AUXVEC2(1)
*ENDDO

VALUE(  1,1) =  1.200
VALUE(  2,1) =  1.000
VALUE(  3,1) =  1.000
VALUE(  4,1) =  50.00
VALUE(  5,1) =  1.619
VALUE(  6,1) =  1.961
VALUE(  7,1) =  1.019
VALUE(  8,1) =  1.000
VALUE(  9,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 10,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 11,1) =  1.439
VALUE( 12,1) =  1.473
VALUE( 13,1) =  0.926
VALUE( 14,1) =  0.776
VALUE( 15,1) =  1.060
VALUE( 16,1) =  0.978
VALUE( 17,1) =  1.325
VALUE( 18,1) =  1.892
VALUE( 19,1) =  0.746
VALUE( 20,1) =  0.767
VALUE( 21,1) =  1.038
VALUE( 22,1) =  1.441
VALUE( 23,1) =  2.018
VALUE( 24,1) =  1.980
VALUE( 25,1) =  0.837
VALUE( 26,1) =  1.128
VALUE( 27,1) =  1.651
VALUE( 28,1) =  1.997
VALUE( 29,1) =  4.011
VALUE( 30,1) =  1.960

~SLPSOL,1,,0.3 ! Bishop
*DO,JJ,1,30
  LABEL(JJ+30) = 'BIS' %JJ+30%
  *DO,II,1,10
    ~CFGET,AUXVECT(II),SLOPE,,RES,F,,2,(JJ-1)*10 + II
  *ENDDO
  *VOPER,AUXVEC2,AUXVECT,MULT,AUXVECT
  *VFUN,AUXVEC2,SQRT,AUXVEC2
  *VFUN,AUXVEC2,ASORT,AUXVEC2
  VALUE(JJ+30,2) = AUXVEC2(1)
*ENDDO

VALUE( 31,1) =  1.319
VALUE( 32,1) =  1.709
VALUE( 33,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 34,1) =  50.00
VALUE( 35,1) =  1.674
VALUE( 36,1) =  2.086
VALUE( 37,1) =  1.494
VALUE( 38,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 39,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 40,1) =  1.677
VALUE( 41,1) =  1.475
VALUE( 42,1) =  1.705
VALUE( 43,1) =  1.294
VALUE( 44,1) =  1.110
VALUE( 45,1) =  1.276
VALUE( 46,1) =  1.174
VALUE( 47,1) =  1.400
VALUE( 48,1) =  1.809
VALUE( 49,1) =  1.101
VALUE( 50,1) =  1.054
VALUE( 51,1) =  1.222
VALUE( 52,1) =  1.545
VALUE( 53,1) =  1.971
VALUE( 54,1) =  2.094
VALUE( 55,1) =  1.100
VALUE( 56,1) =  1.300
VALUE( 57,1) =  1.769
VALUE( 58,1) =  1.996
VALUE( 59,1) =  3.641
VALUE( 60,1) =  2.066

~SLPSOL,2,,0.3 ! Janbu
*DO,JJ,1,30
  LABEL(JJ+60) = 'JAN' %JJ+60%
  *DO,II,1,10
    ~CFGET,AUXVECT(II),SLOPE,,RES,F,,2,(JJ-1)*10 + II
  *ENDDO
  *VOPER,AUXVEC2,AUXVECT,MULT,AUXVECT
  *VFUN,AUXVEC2,SQRT,AUXVEC2
  *VFUN,AUXVEC2,ASORT,AUXVEC2
  VALUE(JJ+60,2) = AUXVEC2(1)
*ENDDO

VALUE( 61,1) =  1.107
VALUE( 62,1) =  1.647
VALUE( 63,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 64,1) =  0.001
VALUE( 65,1) =  1.568
VALUE( 66,1) =  1.899
VALUE( 67,1) =  1.495
VALUE( 68,1) =  1.725
VALUE( 69,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 70,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 71,1) =  1.405
VALUE( 72,1) =  0.002
VALUE( 73,1) =  1.285
VALUE( 74,1) =  1.103
VALUE( 75,1) =  1.335
VALUE( 76,1) =  1.271
VALUE( 77,1) =  1.794
VALUE( 78,1) =  1.944
VALUE( 79,1) =  1.065
VALUE( 80,1) =  1.044
VALUE( 81,1) =  1.264
VALUE( 82,1) =  1.703
VALUE( 83,1) =  2.890
VALUE( 84,1) =  1.945
VALUE( 85,1) =  1.087
VALUE( 86,1) =  1.329
VALUE( 87,1) =  1.864
VALUE( 88,1) =  2.459
VALUE( 89,1) =  5.000
VALUE( 90,1) =  1.930

~SLPSOL,3,,0.3! Modified Janbu
*DO,JJ,1,30
  LABEL(JJ+90) = 'JMD' %JJ+90%
  *DO,II,1,10
    ~CFGET,AUXVECT(II),SLOPE,,RES,F,,2,(JJ-1)*10 + II
  *ENDDO
  *VOPER,AUXVEC2,AUXVECT,MULT,AUXVECT
  *VFUN,AUXVEC2,SQRT,AUXVEC2
  *VFUN,AUXVEC2,ASORT,AUXVEC2
  VALUE(JJ+90,2) = AUXVEC2(1)
*ENDDO

VALUE( 91,1) =  1.1920
VALUE( 92,1) =  1.7166
VALUE( 93,1) =  1.0250
VALUE( 94,1) =  0.0011
VALUE( 95,1) =  1.6842
VALUE( 96,1) =  2.0440
VALUE( 97,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 98,1) =  1.000
VALUE( 99,1) =  1.000
VALUE(100,1) =  2.2743
VALUE(101,1) =  1.4894
VALUE(102,1) =  0.0021
VALUE(103,1) =  1.3245
VALUE(104,1) =  1.1440
VALUE(105,1) =  1.3896
VALUE(106,1) =  1.3343
VALUE(107,1) =  1.9044
VALUE(108,1) =  2.0820
VALUE(109,1) =  1.0974
VALUE(110,1) =  1.0816
VALUE(111,1) =  1.3181
VALUE(112,1) =  1.7989
VALUE(113,1) =  3.1336
VALUE(114,1) =  2.1184
VALUE(115,1) =  1.1216
VALUE(116,1) =  1.3790
VALUE(117,1) =  1.9485
VALUE(118,1) =  2.6097
VALUE(119,1) =  5.000
VALUE(120,1) =  2.0601

! Warning and error tolerances
  *DO,II,1,NComp
    TOLER(II,1) = VALUE(II,1)*0.05
    TOLER(II,2) = VALUE(II,1)*0.05
  *ENDDO
! Known exceptions
  I=  2 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I=  3 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40
  I=  4 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90
  I=  7 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I=  8 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I=  9 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40
  I= 10 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 11 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 13 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 15 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.25  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.25
  I= 19 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.25  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.25
  I= 17 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 18 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 20 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 21 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 22 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 23 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 25 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 26 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 28 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 29 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 32 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 33 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90
  I= 34 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90
  I= 38 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 39 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40
  I= 40 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40
  I= 37 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 41 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 43 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 44 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 45 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.25  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.25
  I= 46 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 47 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 49 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 50 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 51 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 52 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 55 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 56 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 57 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 62 $ TOLER(  I,1) = 100  $  TOLER(  I,2) = 100 ! Ignored
  I= 63 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90
  I= 64 $ TOLER(  I,1) = 100  $  TOLER(  I,2) = 100 ! Ignored
  I= 67 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.40
  I= 68 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.45  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.45
  I= 69 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 70 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 72 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*1e6   $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*1e6
  I= 73 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.25  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.25
  I= 74 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 75 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 76 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 77 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 79 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 80 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 81 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 82 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 83 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 85 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 86 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 87 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 88 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 89 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 92 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.35  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.35
  I= 93 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90
  I= 94 $ TOLER(  I,1) = 100  $  TOLER(  I,2) = 100 ! Ignored
  I= 97 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 98 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.2     $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.2
  I= 99 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 100 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.50  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.50
  I= 102 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*1e6   $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*1e6
  I= 103 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 104 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 105 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 106 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 107 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 109 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.10  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.10
  I= 110 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.10  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.10
  I= 111 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 112 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 113 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 115 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.15
  I= 116 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.90
  I= 117 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20
  I= 118 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.30
  I= 119 $ TOLER(  I,1) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20  $  TOLER(  I,2) = VALUE(I,1)*0.20

!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
! 12. Results comparison
!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  COMPARA.MAC

Results

LabelTargetCivilFEMRatioTolerance
'FEL'1 1.2 1.23130.974 0.06
'FEL'2 1 0.905191.095 0.2
'FEL'3 1 0.707411.293 0.4
'FEL'4 50 59.7120.806 45
'FEL'5 1.619 1.62670.995 0.08095
'FEL'6 1.961 1.97310.994 0.09805
'FEL'7 1.019 1.10130.919 0.2038
'FEL'8 1 0.824481.176 0.3
'FEL'9 1 0.67791.322 0.4
'FEL'10 1 0.805881.194 0.3
'FEL'11 1.439 1.26811.119 0.2158
'FEL'12 1.473 1.48460.992 0.07365
'FEL'13 0.926 0.984960.936 0.1852
'FEL'14 0.776 0.777420.998 0.0388
'FEL'15 1.06 0.841871.206 0.265
'FEL'16 0.978 1.02260.954 0.0489
'FEL'17 1.325 1.211.087 0.1988
'FEL'18 1.892 1.67031.117 0.2838
'FEL'19 0.746 0.910820.779 0.1865
'FEL'20 0.767 0.886570.844 0.1534
'FEL'21 1.038 1.15540.887 0.2076
'FEL'22 1.441 1.35121.062 0.2162
'FEL'23 2.018 1.90661.055 0.3027
'FEL'24 1.98 1.9880.996 0.099
'FEL'25 0.837 0.980460.829 0.1674
'FEL'26 1.128 1.24770.894 0.1692
'FEL'27 1.651 1.591.037 0.08255
'FEL'28 1.997 1.86961.064 0.2995
'FEL'29 4.011 3.55491.114 0.6017
'FEL'30 1.96 1.96730.996 0.098
'BIS'31 1.319 1.31021.007 0.06595
'BIS'32 1.709 1.53061.104 0.3418
'BIS'33 1 1.56260.437 0.9
'BIS'34 50 52.0320.959 45
'BIS'35 1.674 1.65551.011 0.0837
'BIS'36 2.086 2.07561.005 0.1043
'BIS'37 1.494 1.48451.006 0.2241
'BIS'38 1 1.28320.717 0.3
'BIS'39 1 1.31410.686 0.4
'BIS'40 1.677 1.19851.285 0.6708
'BIS'41 1.475 1.35721.080 0.2213
'BIS'42 1.705 1.69251.007 0.08525
'BIS'43 1.294 1.29660.998 0.1941
'BIS'44 1.11 1.1550.959 0.1665
'BIS'45 1.276 1.1391.107 0.319
'BIS'46 1.174 1.18170.993 0.1761
'BIS'47 1.4 1.34921.036 0.21
'BIS'48 1.809 1.76141.026 0.09045
'BIS'49 1.101 1.18030.928 0.1651
'BIS'50 1.054 1.08250.973 0.1581
'BIS'51 1.222 1.22660.996 0.1833
'BIS'52 1.545 1.45821.056 0.2318
'BIS'53 1.971 1.97450.998 0.09855
'BIS'54 2.094 2.0951.000 0.1047
'BIS'55 1.1 1.11510.986 0.165
'BIS'56 1.3 1.29541.004 0.195
'BIS'57 1.769 1.67971.051 0.2653
'BIS'58 1.996 1.92061.038 0.0998
'BIS'59 3.641 3.47471.046 0.182
'BIS'60 2.066 2.06760.999 0.1033
'JAN'61 1.107 1.11110.996 0.05535
'JAN'62 1.647 1.12831.315 100
'JAN'63 1 1.33860.661 0.9
'JAN'64 0.001 920.000 100
'JAN'65 1.568 1.58280.991 0.0784
'JAN'66 1.899 1.9160.991 0.09495
'JAN'67 1.495 1.10371.262 0.598
'JAN'68 1.725 1.03411.401 0.7763
'JAN'69 1 0.97251.028 0.2
'JAN'70 1 1.07090.929 0.2
'JAN'71 1.405 1.4090.997 0.07025
'JAN'72 0.002 1.45690.000 2000
'JAN'73 1.285 1.02371.203 0.3212
'JAN'74 1.103 0.923851.162 0.2206
'JAN'75 1.335 0.94611.291 0.4005
'JAN'76 1.271 1.08911.143 0.2542
'JAN'77 1.794 1.34151.252 0.5382
'JAN'78 1.944 1.95190.996 0.0972
'JAN'79 1.065 0.967091.092 0.1598
'JAN'80 1.044 0.947121.093 0.1566
'JAN'81 1.264 1.12951.106 0.2528
'JAN'82 1.703 1.37911.190 0.3406
'JAN'83 2.89 2.10291.272 0.867
'JAN'84 1.945 1.95420.995 0.09725
'JAN'85 1.087 0.986551.092 0.1631
'JAN'86 1.329 1.1921.103 0.2658
'JAN'87 1.864 1.55941.163 0.3728
'JAN'88 2.459 1.91441.222 0.7377
'JAN'89 5 5.30680.939 1
'JAN'90 1.93 1.93870.996 0.0965
'JMD'91 1.192 1.19670.996 0.0596
'JMD'92 1.7166 1.18741.308 0.6008
'JMD'93 1.025 1.46490.571 0.9225
'JMD'94 0.0011 920.000 100
'JMD'95 1.6842 1.70030.990 0.08421
'JMD'96 2.044 2.07330.986 0.1022
'JMD'97 1 1.15570.844 0.2
'JMD'98 1 1.08530.915 0.2
'JMD'99 1 1.02480.975 0.2
'JMD'100 2.2743 1.17121.485 1.137
'JMD'101 1.4894 1.49370.997 0.07447
'JMD'102 0.0021 1.58580.000 2100
'JMD'103 1.3245 1.071.192 0.2649
'JMD'104 1.144 0.968361.154 0.2288
'JMD'105 1.3896 0.994221.285 0.4169
'JMD'106 1.3343 1.18691.111 0.2669
'JMD'107 1.9044 1.46431.231 0.5713
'JMD'108 2.082 2.09160.995 0.1041
'JMD'109 1.0974 1.00931.080 0.1097
'JMD'110 1.0816 0.989891.085 0.1082
'JMD'111 1.3181 1.22211.073 0.2636
'JMD'112 1.7989 1.4941.170 0.3598
'JMD'113 3.1336 2.28011.272 0.9401
'JMD'114 2.1184 2.08931.014 0.1059
'JMD'115 1.1216 1.02671.085 0.1682
'JMD'116 1.379 1.27921.072 1.241
'JMD'117 1.9485 1.67761.139 0.3897
'JMD'118 2.6097 2.0591.211 0.7829
'JMD'119 5 5.69820.860 1
'JMD'120 2.0601 2.06940.996 0.103

Contains proprietary and confidential information of Ingeciber, S.A.